Tuesday, May 31, 2011

Old Hungappa Material 3: A thought on skepticism

Note: For people who don't read the Hungappa (or more basically, anyone who doesn't go to CSU Wagga), Epic Things Collated is a weekly column penned by a friend of mine; if he ever comes online with his material, I'll link over.

So a friend of mine over at Epic Things Collated asked me for my opinion on the state of freedom of/from religion in Australia (he is, in fact, writing an article in the next room). He comes from the Carl Sagan school of thought, and by and large feels that, with a few notable exceptions, we are generally in a good place right now.

I wish it were so, but alas! It is not meant to be, yet. Take this, for instance: I want to start a student group for debate; a simultaneous house of learning about ideas, and an arena for their testing. I think we can agree, at least superficially, that ideas need to be tested; probed for weaknesses; to weed out the bad ones and strengthen the good ones.

This is skepticism; the school of turning an observant eye over a concept and the arguments that support it. It’s a useful tool in so many ways, and for so many fields, yet most of us aren’t in any major way formally trained in it. If we had a place to discuss these things; the ‘appeals to nature/tradition/novelty/children’ and the ‘straw man’ and ‘slippery slope’ arguments, maybe we could discern more clearly between obfuscation and the truth, particularly in a time when terms like ‘PR’, ‘spin’ and the ‘media cycle’ are becoming increasingly relevant.

Imagine my complete lack of surprise when, asking for a critique of this germinating concept, I’m told that I need to be clear this isn’t ‘an atheist group’, to avoid offending religious student groups on campus.

Employing my own imagination for a moment, I’m led to suggest several points:
1)      There seems to be a clear link in the public consciousness between skepticism and atheism, for good or ill. This could be due to:
2)      The politicisation of atheism, particularly the rise of New Atheism as a countercultural movement against an increasing number of fundamentalist religious groups,
3)      The varying levels of connection between atheistic, skeptic/’freethinking’ and secularist groups, and finally
4)      The identification by religious groups in varying degrees, of the threat skepticism poses to arguments from religion

I suppose some part of it is inevitable; faith (which usually used in the religious context constitutes ‘blind faith’) is required to persist even in the face of conflicting evidence. Furthermore, it protects itself by claiming sanctity, a ‘holiness’ that guarantees offence or insult when questioned. Nothing; no other idea, except for the most extreme of political ideologies, tries to lay claim to that. Sure, people tend to take offence when any of their ideas are questioned (a habit we need to get out of), but religion effectively guarantees it.

So what the above really means is that, if I try to start up a group promoting skepticism, I’m likely to offend people on the mere basis of its existence. Just ‘being’ will be enough to anger people. If this is the case, we can’t possibly be in a good place vis-à-vis freedom of/from religion.

Just a thought or two, to ponder on while you’re eating/drinking/doing whatever.

-#

No comments:

Post a Comment