Tuesday, May 31, 2011

Old Hungappa Material 3: A thought on skepticism

Note: For people who don't read the Hungappa (or more basically, anyone who doesn't go to CSU Wagga), Epic Things Collated is a weekly column penned by a friend of mine; if he ever comes online with his material, I'll link over.

So a friend of mine over at Epic Things Collated asked me for my opinion on the state of freedom of/from religion in Australia (he is, in fact, writing an article in the next room). He comes from the Carl Sagan school of thought, and by and large feels that, with a few notable exceptions, we are generally in a good place right now.

I wish it were so, but alas! It is not meant to be, yet. Take this, for instance: I want to start a student group for debate; a simultaneous house of learning about ideas, and an arena for their testing. I think we can agree, at least superficially, that ideas need to be tested; probed for weaknesses; to weed out the bad ones and strengthen the good ones.

This is skepticism; the school of turning an observant eye over a concept and the arguments that support it. It’s a useful tool in so many ways, and for so many fields, yet most of us aren’t in any major way formally trained in it. If we had a place to discuss these things; the ‘appeals to nature/tradition/novelty/children’ and the ‘straw man’ and ‘slippery slope’ arguments, maybe we could discern more clearly between obfuscation and the truth, particularly in a time when terms like ‘PR’, ‘spin’ and the ‘media cycle’ are becoming increasingly relevant.

Imagine my complete lack of surprise when, asking for a critique of this germinating concept, I’m told that I need to be clear this isn’t ‘an atheist group’, to avoid offending religious student groups on campus.

Employing my own imagination for a moment, I’m led to suggest several points:
1)      There seems to be a clear link in the public consciousness between skepticism and atheism, for good or ill. This could be due to:
2)      The politicisation of atheism, particularly the rise of New Atheism as a countercultural movement against an increasing number of fundamentalist religious groups,
3)      The varying levels of connection between atheistic, skeptic/’freethinking’ and secularist groups, and finally
4)      The identification by religious groups in varying degrees, of the threat skepticism poses to arguments from religion

I suppose some part of it is inevitable; faith (which usually used in the religious context constitutes ‘blind faith’) is required to persist even in the face of conflicting evidence. Furthermore, it protects itself by claiming sanctity, a ‘holiness’ that guarantees offence or insult when questioned. Nothing; no other idea, except for the most extreme of political ideologies, tries to lay claim to that. Sure, people tend to take offence when any of their ideas are questioned (a habit we need to get out of), but religion effectively guarantees it.

So what the above really means is that, if I try to start up a group promoting skepticism, I’m likely to offend people on the mere basis of its existence. Just ‘being’ will be enough to anger people. If this is the case, we can’t possibly be in a good place vis-à-vis freedom of/from religion.

Just a thought or two, to ponder on while you’re eating/drinking/doing whatever.

-#

Old Hungappa Material 2: Pet Peeves in Arguing


Note: I really dislike the title, but titles have never been my strong suit. Was hoping the editor could think up something catchier, but I neglected to mention it.

“No cause is so noble that it won’t attract fuggheads.”
-Larry Niven, Fallen Angels

As someone who identifies as a freethinker and a skeptic, I take arguments seriously; manner, method and matter are all important. You can’t be taken seriously unless you treat the meat, the structure, and delivery seriously, right? Obviously I’m not talking about mundane things, like what to cook for dinner; I’m talking about serious issues, like immigration policy, or disability support, or marriage equality.

Time and time again I encounter things people do while arguing that leave me wondering why I didn’t take up an easier pastime... like ballistics engineering or MasterChef. Of those, these four grievances were the first to come to mind (and coincidentally, the only ones I can fit in 500 words).

Pet Peeve #1: 'They' use arguments that were proven wrong before they were born.

‘They’. You know who I’m talking about; lazy pricks who haven’t even bothered to look up the history of the topic. Come on, you’re not even trying to do this properly (trolls notwithstanding).

Pet Peeve #2: You've taken the time to research and support your arguments with relevant citations, which the other person dismisses without even looking.

I’m sorry; I don’t think I said, “Yeah sure, no worries; mouth off all you like without thinking. Of course it doesn’t matter if you take a great big steaming dump on my effort, as long as you’re happy.” I put thought into giving you something deserving to be looked at; least you could do is respect that.

Pet Peeve #3: You're arguing with someone, and you successfully counter one of their arguments head-on, when they abruptly change tack and ignore your refutation.

Please, please don't do this. It gives me a facial tic, and the desire to start fires. As the only President Who Mattered* said, 'No. No "however". Just be wrong. Just stand there in your wrongness and be wrong and get used to it.' I've made my point, and the only reasonable thing to do is take in onboard and accept it. Accept your idea was wrong; hold a funeral for it if you must, but either way bury it, because it’s dead. Sometimes though, when people love an argument too much to let it go, it claws from the grave in a dishevelled state, out for brains, which leads me to...

Pet Peeve #4: You've argued a particular subject with someone multiple times, and each time they always bring up the same arguments, regardless of whether some have been proven wrong. Bonus points if they've admitted they're wrong in the past.

'Zombie' arguments: the ones that just won't stay dead. These make we wonder how prehistoric humanity ever left the cave. On the other hand, try being cooped up in a cave with someone who does this, and see if it doesn’t inspire you to try your hand at early livestock domestication or wheat cultivation.

*President Josiah Bartlett, The West Wing. I might be showing my (relative) age.

Old Hungappa Material 1: Appeal to Nature

Note: this was the first of my articles I had published in Hungappa. Took me some time to find my feet; this was August last year. Some slight edits to account for the electronic presentation; thought it might be nice to keep for future reference.

 
I’m #, and I like arguing about things. Asylum seekers, evolution, same-sex marriage, the nature of religion, nuclear power, climate change...they’re all things I can really sink my teeth into. Anyway, I was having an argument with somebody on Facebook yesterday, and after I bit I had to go into a prac. No big deal, except it completely blew up while I was away. Like scorched earth; bodies lying everywhere and all that.
Setting about to pick up the pieces today, it occurred to me that people often argue without trying to grapple the nature of their opponent’s arguments. It seems completely absurd to me that you’d try to convince someone of your views without trying to understand the basis of theirs. In essence, you end up with two sides where nobody understands each other, and everybody’s angry over yelling themselves hoarse.
What I’d like to do is go over a few conventional arguments that people make, and pick them apart. I’m not an Arts student, and a lot of my understanding here is self-taught. If I say anything misleading, or my argument contains logical flaws, please feel free to let me know.
Refuting the 'Appeal to Nature':

The 'appeal to nature' is a common argument used to justify an opinion of goodness or badness about something with respect to how natural or unnatural it is. For instance, some people may claim herbal supplements are good because they are natural. Conversely, some people claim that homosexuality is bad because it is unnatural.

Now, you could argue that pesticides used in the production of herbal supplements reduce their 'natural' component. You could also argue that homosexuality is completely natural, developing as it could through evolutionary psychology.

The point is, all of these arguments are irrelevant, because the appeal to nature is a fallacy. The 'natural' or 'unnatural' nature of something does not prove in any way its goodness or badness. Let me demonstrate. A tendency towards violence is, for some individuals, biologically predetermined. It's natural, but not good, morally speaking. Same goes for a world of drugs and poisons found in nature, from cocaine to strychnine. St. John’s Wort, a commonly used natural antidepressant, can do a world of harm if taken in the wrong context.

On the other hand, fidelity in sexual relationships might not be entirely natural from a biological standpoint, but it’s something we approve of. Likewise, many drugs used in modern medicine are completely synthesised, and are good to use in the right therapeutic context. We certainly didn’t evolve with wings, but commercial airflight has been good in providing us with the ability to travel great distances and connect with more people.
So, in short, the ‘appeal to nature’ is false because you can’t prove whether something is good or not by simply referring to how natural it is.
Other related arguments include the ‘appeal to tradition’ (by saying that something is good because it’s been done for a long period of time), or the ‘moralistic fallacy’ (by saying something couldn’t be a part of natural because it is immoral).
Well, I need to get ready for another prac now. Have fun!

the pre-introduction

One usually opens a blog with an introductory post, but with a genetics assessment tomorrow, I'll hold off and just upload some older material for now.

-#