I’m #, and I like arguing about things. Asylum seekers, evolution, same-sex marriage, the nature of religion, nuclear power, climate change...they’re all things I can really sink my teeth into. Anyway, I was having an argument with somebody on Facebook yesterday, and after I bit I had to go into a prac. No big deal, except it completely blew up while I was away. Like scorched earth; bodies lying everywhere and all that.
Setting about to pick up the pieces today, it occurred to me that people often argue without trying to grapple the nature of their opponent’s arguments. It seems completely absurd to me that you’d try to convince someone of your views without trying to understand the basis of theirs. In essence, you end up with two sides where nobody understands each other, and everybody’s angry over yelling themselves hoarse.
What I’d like to do is go over a few conventional arguments that people make, and pick them apart. I’m not an Arts student, and a lot of my understanding here is self-taught. If I say anything misleading, or my argument contains logical flaws, please feel free to let me know.
Refuting the 'Appeal to Nature':
The 'appeal to nature' is a common argument used to justify an opinion of goodness or badness about something with respect to how natural or unnatural it is. For instance, some people may claim herbal supplements are good because they are natural. Conversely, some people claim that homosexuality is bad because it is unnatural.
Now, you could argue that pesticides used in the production of herbal supplements reduce their 'natural' component. You could also argue that homosexuality is completely natural, developing as it could through evolutionary psychology.
The point is, all of these arguments are irrelevant, because the appeal to nature is a fallacy. The 'natural' or 'unnatural' nature of something does not prove in any way its goodness or badness. Let me demonstrate. A tendency towards violence is, for some individuals, biologically predetermined. It's natural, but not good, morally speaking. Same goes for a world of drugs and poisons found in nature, from cocaine to strychnine. St. John’s Wort, a commonly used natural antidepressant, can do a world of harm if taken in the wrong context.
On the other hand, fidelity in sexual relationships might not be entirely natural from a biological standpoint, but it’s something we approve of. Likewise, many drugs used in modern medicine are completely synthesised, and are good to use in the right therapeutic context. We certainly didn’t evolve with wings, but commercial airflight has been good in providing us with the ability to travel great distances and connect with more people.
The 'appeal to nature' is a common argument used to justify an opinion of goodness or badness about something with respect to how natural or unnatural it is. For instance, some people may claim herbal supplements are good because they are natural. Conversely, some people claim that homosexuality is bad because it is unnatural.
Now, you could argue that pesticides used in the production of herbal supplements reduce their 'natural' component. You could also argue that homosexuality is completely natural, developing as it could through evolutionary psychology.
The point is, all of these arguments are irrelevant, because the appeal to nature is a fallacy. The 'natural' or 'unnatural' nature of something does not prove in any way its goodness or badness. Let me demonstrate. A tendency towards violence is, for some individuals, biologically predetermined. It's natural, but not good, morally speaking. Same goes for a world of drugs and poisons found in nature, from cocaine to strychnine. St. John’s Wort, a commonly used natural antidepressant, can do a world of harm if taken in the wrong context.
On the other hand, fidelity in sexual relationships might not be entirely natural from a biological standpoint, but it’s something we approve of. Likewise, many drugs used in modern medicine are completely synthesised, and are good to use in the right therapeutic context. We certainly didn’t evolve with wings, but commercial airflight has been good in providing us with the ability to travel great distances and connect with more people.
So, in short, the ‘appeal to nature’ is false because you can’t prove whether something is good or not by simply referring to how natural it is.
Other related arguments include the ‘appeal to tradition’ (by saying that something is good because it’s been done for a long period of time), or the ‘moralistic fallacy’ (by saying something couldn’t be a part of natural because it is immoral).
Well, I need to get ready for another prac now. Have fun!
No comments:
Post a Comment