Welcome to week three! The week, where at least as far as science students are concerned, you’ll be writing your first prac reports! Fun fun fun! I don’t know what you other guys are up to, but I’m sure it’s just as illuminating and entertaining.
I was going to write a piece on secularism, but it’ll have to wait because inspiration came calling in the form of a friend from Monash who also keeps a blog. Anyway, he styles himself as ‘The Young Conservative’ and he left me a rather delightful piece for my Saturday morning read, titled ‘Real Men Don’t: First Edition’. Could’ve been exciting, but it turned out to be a four paragraph-long swipe at guys who get tattoos and piercings. A whinge; how boring.
Let’s make it more interesting by asking this: what is a ‘Real Man’, and do they exist?
If you asked me a couple of years ago to conjure up an image of the Real Man, I’d probably have described him as strong and silent; stoic; able to bear up under pressure without complaining or crying; emotionally in control; serious. Alternatively, maybe he’s good for a laugh; goes out with the boys; a team player; enjoys a beer; a fair hand with a cricket bat or a football. In his relationships with women (be they mothers, sisters, girlfriends), he is the breadwinner and the guardian, provider of material wealth and protection; he is ready to defend the ‘honour’ of a female family member, with fists flying if need be. To that end, he probably exercises a lot, with emphasis on weight training; got to bulk up after all. Also, it probably goes without saying he’s a hot-blooded heterosexual, and able-bodied.
In short, he’s an ideal; something for a man to aspire to, and as something to aspire to, he doesn’t exist; not really anyway. In reality, all a guy can be is an approximation of the Real Man. Is he a healthy ideal? I don’t think so; is it healthy, being expected to ‘drink a cup of concrete’, or isolate one’s self when you have problems and there are others who can help you? Is it healthy to expect one’s self, to set one’s identity or purpose, to be the breadwinner in a society moving towards a righteous equality of opportunity across the sexes? Is it healthy to set someone’s natural sexuality against their gender identity, causing many gay men to feel alien amongst other men?
You know, as far as I can tell, all this ‘Real Man’ stuff; it’s facade. It’s all looks and no substance. It’s about the way you look and act in front of other men; women too. That doesn’t sound real to me.
How about we take the emphasis off ‘male as stereotype’, and instead simply inspire men to be good, huh? How about wanting to be a Good Man, rather than a Real one? Place the emphasis on the doing of things, and not on the acting or appearing? Hell, we could take it one step further; omit the ‘male’ part and simply try to be a good person. Is that so radical?
A quote I found online states that “rhetorical questions often hide the weakest part of an argument”, and I’ve posed my fair share of them here. I do it to save space sometimes; I pose the question and hopefully you’ll get to the same conclusion I do, without me having to explain it. There’s certainly more depth to this than I can present in a (now topping six hundred word) Hungappa column, so please, if you disagree with me; if you agree with me; if you simply want to hear more, track me down at thehumanmisunderstanding.blogspot.com.au and let me know.
Until next week,
C#