Tuesday, August 20, 2013

The one about the free-for-all over price disclosure

So, the Consumers Health Forum (CHF), CHOICE and the Australian Council of Social Service (ACOSS) just stepped up their game in this fight brewing over early price disclosure, issuing a joint media release urging consumers not to sign the petition butohwait here's our petition, and let's tell those pollies we won't stand up to Pharmacy Guild bullying over the cost of our medicines!

Predictably the Guild issued their response, keeping to the same language and points they've kept throughout the 'Under Threat' campaign. Oh, they made some concessions to new points the former brought up, with their retort that pharmaceutical spending as % of GDP is relatively low and falling; claims I really don't want to look into (because I'm sure the Guild wouldn't fudge those numbers; certainly not because it's GDP, which means economics, which means boring).

For the most part though, there's some stuff in the CHF/CHOICE/ACOSS media release that's ripe for investigation. Australian consumers and taxpayers paying ten times the British price for prescriptions?

I don't have time to join the dots, but I'll provide the links for anyone who's interested. If you're going to have a look at them, here are some possible questions to consider:

  • How much do consumers pay for a single subsidised prescription in the UK or NZ relative to here?
  • How much does the government pay for covering the cost of a subsidised prescription in the UK or NZ relative to here?
  • How much do pharmacies make off a single prescription?
  • If pharmacies make so little money off prescriptions in the UK or NZ, how does that affect their viability? Do they provide others services? Are those subsidised by the government as well? What kind of relationship exists between community pharmacy and the patient in those countries? Is community pharmacy over there structured substantially different than to here?


Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme - The Australian system that subsidises the cost of medicines. Explanatory notes here and a list of the fees and how the PBS is applied using examples here.

The Pharmaceutical Management Agency (PHARMAC) - New Zealand's organisation that is responsible for their version of the PBS, the New Zealand Pharmaceutical Schedule

Ministry of Health New Zealand - Prescription Charges - Information on the cost of subsidised medicines in NZ to the consumer.

National Health Service (NHS) - Help with Prescription Costs - The NHS is responsible for all subsidised healthcare in the UK (sort of; from what I can tell, there are slightly different bodies between England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, but whatever). This provides information on the cost of subsidised medicines in England to the consumer.

Unfortunately I can't seem to find information on the cost of individual medicines to the consumer and to the government for the UK; they don't appear to have anything like PBS or the PHARMAC's Pharmaceutical Schedule accessible online. Of course that doesn't mean they don't; maybe I simply haven't looked hard enough. If there is something, I'm betting it'll be somewhere in the NHS Business Services Authority's website for prescription services. If you find it I'd love to know.

Now for some coverage on the issue from other areas:

'Australia's Bad Drug Deal - High pharmaceutical prices' - A report by Stephen Druckett for the Grattan Institute. Compares what the government pay for subsidised medicines here relative to other countries. Pages 31 and 32 are most relevant, but it's a pretty interesting read overall. Published in March earlier this year.

'Pharmacy gravy train drives up the cost of prescription drugs' - Article by Rollo Manning for The Conversation. Came out around the same time as the Grattan Institute report.


1 comment:

  1. PSA responds:

    http://www.psa.org.au/media-releases/psa-challenges-consumer-coalition

    Usually I tend to find things more credible when the PSA says them than when the Guild says them. Saying our 'Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme was the envy of the world' is a bit rich though, unless you give it context. I'm pretty sure the majority of chronic disease sufferers or parents would prefer New Zealand's system ($5 prescriptions up to 20 scrips a year ($100), thereafter all fully subsidised scripts are free, and all prescriptions for kids under 6 are free) or the NHS in the UK (more expensive co-payment than NZ but less than here, and a large number of people get free scripts due to exemptions).

    ReplyDelete