The concept itself has been around in Victoria since 1966, but has, up until recent years, needed to be processed through the court system. The change is supposed to free up the legal system, as well as save the taxpayer money, but at what other costs?
The law allows police officers to issue the fine to someone using 'disorderly', 'offensive', 'threatening', and 'violent' language in a public place. 'Public place' includes everything from the footpath outside your house, to any public hall or theatre which has members of the public in attendance, and any place which has a liquor license (bar, pub, nightclub, etc.).
So you might be thinking that it's good to punish people who verbally threaten others, and I'd agree with you. 'Offensive' though? Even the magistrates themselves acknowledge the ambiguity therein, as community standards change over time.
This is where the problem is: laws cannot afford to be ambiguous. Ambiguity is a barrier to understanding your rights; it also breeds contempt for the law.
An example: if one goes to a comedy show at the Melbourne Town Hall, there's an assumption that there's likely to be offensive language; it's the nature of comedy. What the 'degree' of offensive language will be is up to debate.
What if someone, expecting a degree along the likes of Dylan Moran, ends up seeing something more along the lines of Derek and Clive? They're well within the rights to find the nearest police officer half a block down and complain about it. At that point, what choice does the officer have? The comedian has committed an offence, whether we think it is or not; and whether or not they agree/disagree is likely to be irrelevant, because someone has just reported it.
Another example: take the Good Friday metal gig in Melbourne that earned itself some notoriety a month or two ago. I don't know whether or not it went ahead, or whether or not it should have. The point here is that there's likely to be people highly offended by the premise, and looking for a reason to shut it down. Given the way the law is written, someone is well within the right to complain and have someone fined for offensive language at the venue, even if their motive is ulterior.
An example: if one goes to a comedy show at the Melbourne Town Hall, there's an assumption that there's likely to be offensive language; it's the nature of comedy. What the 'degree' of offensive language will be is up to debate.
What if someone, expecting a degree along the likes of Dylan Moran, ends up seeing something more along the lines of Derek and Clive? They're well within the rights to find the nearest police officer half a block down and complain about it. At that point, what choice does the officer have? The comedian has committed an offence, whether we think it is or not; and whether or not they agree/disagree is likely to be irrelevant, because someone has just reported it.
Another example: take the Good Friday metal gig in Melbourne that earned itself some notoriety a month or two ago. I don't know whether or not it went ahead, or whether or not it should have. The point here is that there's likely to be people highly offended by the premise, and looking for a reason to shut it down. Given the way the law is written, someone is well within the right to complain and have someone fined for offensive language at the venue, even if their motive is ulterior.
Of course, if you receive one of these yourself in future, you could certainly challenge it in court; would you though? For starters, can you afford the cost in legal fees? Free Legal Aid can only go so far, and they can't help if you choose to plead not guilty (or so is my understanding). Also, are you willing to risk trading your $240 fine for a greater one? I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest most people will bite the bullet rather than challenge it as is their right.
I can't do very much about it anymore, having changed my electorate to the Riverina now. If you're still a registered voter in Victoria though, write to your local MP; write to the Victorian Attorney-General, Robert Clark. There's also a protest march being organised in Melbourne; check Facebook for 'fuckwalk'.
TL;DR: If you've got wriggle room in a law, it's
a) confusing, and
b) prone to abuse
a) confusing, and
b) prone to abuse
http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/big-fines-for-those-who-cry-foul-20110530-1fctb.html
http://www.findlaw.com.au/articles/4324/swearing-in-public-in-victoria-it-may-cost-you.aspx
http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/society-and-culture/the-curse-of-the-foullanguage-law-20110531-1fepo.html
http://www.couriermail.com.au/ipad/easter-gig-in-sin-bin/story-fn6ck4a4-1226032869496
http://www.facebook.com/event.php?eid=149006245170490
No comments:
Post a Comment